When faced with mobility limitations and stairs at home become too challenging, people generally face two main options: staying at home with some modifications or moving to a senior living or assisted living facility. Both choices are good, but staying home is more appealing to many Americans.
Home is more than just a physical space; it’s a sanctuary filled with memories of holidays, family gatherings, and moments shared with friends. It’s where life’s most meaningful experiences happen, and staying there helps preserve that sense of comfort and connection.
Some modifications are often necessary to make homes safe and accessible for seniors who remain home. Stairs are one of the biggest concerns for seniors or individuals with limited mobility. Alongside bathrooms, staircases are among the most common areas in a home where accidents can occur. A single misstep could lead to a severe fall, making addressing this potential hazard as a top priority.
Home Elevator or Stairlift?
Most seniors consider installing a home elevator or stairlift to eliminate the stress and risk of navigating stairs. These two pieces of home mobility equipment we install in homes to provide a safe and easy access the stairs. With both options widely used, the question is, which option is best for you?
The answer is not easy, and it depends on various factors. However, this blog will give you an idea of when one option is better.
What are stairlifts?
A stair lift is a motorized chair that makes navigating stairs safe and easy. A certified HomePro Mobility expert installer installs the stairlifts onto the trends of your staicase. This ensures the stairlift can be up and running in just a few hours. If you’re looking for a quick, cost-effective solution to safely access stairs, a stair lift is an excellent choice.
Installing straight stairlifts can often be completed within a day of purchase. Curved stairlifts take a bit longer, as the rail needs to be custom-built, but even these installations are typically completed within a day.
Stair lifts are incredibly versatile, suitable for straight and curved staircases, and can be installed indoors or outdoors. Whether you’re struggling to access a second floor inside your home or need assistance with an outdoor entryway, there are a variety of stair lift models designed to meet your needs.
For added convenience and safety, optional features such as manual or power-folding rails can be included to prevent the rail from becoming a tripping hazard at the bottom of the stairs.
What is a Home Elevator?
A home elevator is a more premium option than a stair lift. However it offers many benefits, making it a compelling choice for those seeking a safe and convenient way to move between floors. While the initial investment is higher, the long-term advantages and added value to your home often make it worthwhile.
One of the key benefits of installing a home elevator is the increase in property value. Although it’s a significant upfront expense, a large portion of that cost is retained in the added market appeal of your home. This makes a home elevator a functional upgrade and a smart investment.
Home Elevator vs Stairlift: Appearance
When it comes to appearance and design, stairlifts and elevators offer distinctly different aesthetics. Stairlifts are more noticeable since they are mounted directly onto the staircase and cannot be fully concealed. However, many models are designed to minimize their appearance when not in use, with seats, footrests, and armrests that can fold away neatly when not in use.
While stairlifts prioritize function over form, they often come with customizable options such as different seat finishes, colors, and rail materials, allowing you to choose a look that fits your home. Some models also include safety features like swivel seats, armrests, footrests, and safety belts.
Elevators, on the other hand, can be more seamlessly integrated into your home’s design. Traditional shaft elevators can be concealed with stylish panels or doors that blend into the decor. Inside are many customization options, from wall finishes and lighting to flooring and handrails, making matching your taste and home style easy.
Non-shaft elevators, like pneumatic elevators, offer a different aesthetic for those who prefer a more compact solution. These modern designs often feature clear glass or plastic tubes, creating a sleek, open look. While they don’t offer as many decorative options, their minimalist design allows them to fit into smaller spaces. In some cases, they can be strategically concealed within your home layout.
Home Elevator vs a Stairlift: Costs
The total installation cost for elevators and stairlifts is included in the final quote you pay the installation company. HomePro Mobility provides a free consultation with our qualified team to discuss your mobility needs, assess your stairs, recommend the perfect stairlift, and provide a quote for the total installation cost.
In most cases, the average cost of a new stairlift can range from $3000 to $5,000, with pre-owned stairlifts going as low as $ 2000. You should contact HomePro Mobility or another trusted mobility company and talk to an expert about the exact cost of the stairlift and stairlift installation.
On the other hand, elevators are more expensive and have a more comprehensive range of costs due to the many types and installation options available. A pneumatic elevator typically costs around $10,000 to install for a single-floor rise, with the elevator priced between $5,000 and $7,000. A hydraulic elevator is a more significant investment, costing approximately $20,000 for installation when serving just one floor, with the elevator accounting for about $10,000.
Home Elevator vs a Stairlift: Space
When choosing between stair lifts and elevators, space is an important factor. Stairlifts come in various widths to fit different staircases, but not all manufacturers offer models narrow enough for very tight stairwells. In some cases, removing a railing may be necessary to accommodate the lift, which could add money for patching drywall.
While options for narrow stairways exist, they may be more limited. Most stairlifts can fold up when not in use, allowing others to access the stairs. A standard stair lift with a seat has a depth of around 15 inches, but wheelchair-compatible platforms may take up the entire stairwell width, about three feet.
Elevators also vary in size, with code-compliant models ranging from 12 sq. ft. (3 x 4 feet) to a maximum of 18 sq. ft. Shaft elevators often require extra space for the motor. In contrast, pneumatic elevators are more compact, needing only room for the cab.
Home Elevator vs a Stair Lift: Installation
When it comes to installation, stairlifts are the faster, easier, and more budget-friendly option. Most stairlifts can be professionally installed in just three to four hours. Some companies even offer DIY kits for homeowners, but we recommend professional installation, especially for curved staircases or custom chairs, to ensure safety and proper functionality.
Elevators, on the other hand, require more time and effort. Traditional shaft elevators can take up to three weeks to install, given the need for extensive construction and specialized equipment. Non-shaft elevators, like pneumatic models, are quicker and simpler, often installed within a few days.
Home Elevator vs a Stair Lift: Noise
Both stairlifts and elevators produce some noise, but the type and amount can vary. Cable-driven elevators are typically the loudest due to the machinery involved, while pneumatic elevators are much quieter, making them a better choice for noise-sensitive environments. Stairlifts, in general, are designed to operate with minimal noise, ensuring they’re not disruptive during everyday use.
Adding acoustic paneling can help reduce noise levels by absorbing sound if you’re installing an elevator with a shaft. However, for homes with multiple occupants, it’s wise to place the elevator away from bedrooms or other areas where quiet is essential. This thoughtful placement can make a big difference in maintaining peace and comfort in your home.
Home Elevator vs a Stair Lift: Operation
stairlifts are relatively easy to use and install, plugging into a standard 120v outlet and featuring battery-powered remote controls. These allow users to call or send the lift as needed. Users are secured with a seatbelt, and footrest sensors help prevent pinch points for users and pets. However, the exposed rails may pose a tripping hazard for others in the household.
On the other hand, elevators address many home mobility challenges. Most models are wheelchair-friendly and include safety sensors to stop the lift if obstructed. A step-free entrance eliminates trip hazards, and emergency lowering features ensure safety during power outages. Added conveniences, such as in-car phones and optional fold-down seats, make home lifts a superior choice for accessibility and comfort.
Final Words
Installing stairlifts is an affordable option and the best choice for seniors and those with mobility issues to improve their mobility and freedom within their homes. They are easier to install, take less space, and are affordable compared to home elevators.
On the other hand, home elevators are ideal if you want to move heavy items or more people or if you are considering using a wheelchair. Before deciding, you should consider your home layout, budget, and how you plan to use the equipment. Stairlifts are affordable and improve your mobility and safety. With many stairlifts and customization options available, you will find the stairlift that suits and blends with your lifestyle.
Are you ready to reclaim your independence? Contact HomePro Mobility today. Our dedicated team is available to conduct an in-house assessment and discuss the best options based on your stair’s layout, budget, and preferences.
FAQs
FAQs
1. Which is better for seniors, a stairlift or a home elevator?
Both options have benefits, but it depends on your needs. Stairlifts are more affordable, faster to install, and take up less space, while elevators offer added convenience for wheelchair users and greater property value.
2. How much does a stairlift cost compared to a home elevator?
Stairlifts typically cost between $3,000 and $5,000, while home elevators can range from $10,000 to over $20,000 depending on the type and installation.
3. Can stairlifts or home elevators be customized?
Yes! Stairlifts offer various colors and seat styles, while home elevators provide extensive customization options, including finishes, lighting, and design styles to match your home’s decor.
